Janell Goodrich York: Spotlight on Letting Go of Perfect & a Giveaway
I hope you enjoy this spotlight post from Janell Goodrich York about her new Women’s Fiction release, Letting Go of Perfect.
Be sure to comment below by November 3 for a chance to win a paperback of Janell’s new novel AND the first book in The Sisterhood Pie Pact series, The Day Sarah Ran Away! (US address only)
What started out as a stand-alone book, The Day Sarah Ran Away, unexpectedly became a series. Before I typed, “The End” on the last page of book one, I knew I wasn’t ready to say goodbye to Delores, Irene, Agnus, Bea, or Sarah.
So, I began writing book two, Letting Go of Perfect. This story is set in Sarah’s fictional home town. The point of view alternates between Olivia Piercey’s and Teddy Patterson’s point of view. Both characters are mentioned in book one. Olivia is Sarah’s neighbor. Teddy is Bea’s son.
As the overall themes developed for book two, there were several questions I pondered. For example, what does perfect look like? What causes someone to be a perfectionist? How does a perfectionist let go of perfectionism? How does it feel when the imagined picture-perfect image doesn’t match reality? How do we forgive others who have hurt us? How do we forgive ourselves? Which one is easier–forgiving others or ourselves? And where would the “sisterhood” fit into all of this?
I’m hoping Olivia’s story will appeal to a wide range of readers. She’s younger than the other ladies and a parent of two children. She’s an elementary teacher and a recent college graduate. But don’t let her accomplishments fool you, she’s had heartache and betrayal.
Teddy’s story was harder to write. He’s charming and funny. Some of his lines had me swooning, even though writing romance is awkward for me. He’s also grieving and heartbroken. In a few chapters, it was difficult to type with tears streaming down my cheeks.
Adding the free-spirited Irene character to the sisterhood was fun. She is also mentioned in book one. She’s a wonderful addition to the group of ladies.
I based the setting on a combination of three towns in my area. I was in the fifth grade when my dad and I moved to a small town. It changed my life. I thought we’d moved to Mayberry. It was important to me to convey in this book the sense of belonging and gratitude I have for the people who made us feel at home.
While the stories and characters are fictional, I enjoy leaving a few subtle references from my childhood in my books for my family to find.
If you enjoy small town nostalgia, second chances, community, friendships, redemption, humor, and a little romance—grab a slice of pie, your favorite beverage, and a copy of Letting Go of Perfect.
Thanks so much for sharing about your new release, Janell. It sounds like another great story! May God continue to bless you on your writing and publishing journey.
Visit the #HopeFilledFiction blog and comment on Janell Goodrich York’s spotlight post for a chance to win books 1 & 2 in The Sisterhood Pie Pact series! #giveaway #womensfiction
TweetJoin the conversation. Have you read Janell’s first book, The Day Sarah Ran Away? Does Letting Go of Perfect sound like a story you’d like to read? What questions and comments do you have for Janell?
Be sure to comment below by November 3 for a chance to win both of Janell’s books in The Sisterhood Pie Pact series! (US address only)

Letting Go of Perfect by Janell Goodrich York
Click the book cover for Amazon link
When the perfect life falls apart, something better may be waiting.
Starting over wasn’t part of the plan. But with two young children depending on her, Olivia moves her family from the city to a small town, a new job, and the chance to build a life that belongs to her.
An invitation to a book club draws her into the unexpected circle of the Sisterhood Pie Pact women, who provide friendship, community, and a little mischief.
Then she meets Teddy.
A devoted single father, Teddy carries his own broken past. Still haunted by the accident that changed his life, he has spent years allowing guilt to convince him that happiness belongs to everyone but him.
As Olivia settles into her new life, her friendship with Teddy deepens. But moving forward means confronting old wounds, releasing expectations, and deciding whether the past will continue defining the future.
With a little faith, a lot of friendship, and plenty of pie, Olivia begins to discover that starting over may be less about rebuilding what she lost and more about embracing what comes next.
For readers drawn to the emotional depth of For One More Day, the family relationships of The Chicken Sisters, and heartfelt women’s fiction about second chances.
Discover a story of family, friendship, faith, and the courage to let go of perfect.
Janell Goodrich York is a retired high school guidance counselor. She was raised in a small town in Southwest Missouri. Janell enjoys traveling, especially to beach destinations. She loves to hang out with her family and spoil her two dogs. Janell is a girl mom of three awesome daughters and Meme to five “perfect” grandkids. Janell lives in Missouri with her wonderful husband.
Her debut novel, The Day Sarah Ran Away, won third place in the 2026 Selah Contemporary Women’s Fiction Category. Her novel also won third place for Best Fiction in the Missouri Writers Guild Awards. Janell’s second novel in the Sisterhood Pie Pact Series, Letting Go of Perfect, releases in October 2026.

Please share Janell’s spotlight post on social media to help spread the word about her books!
If you missed Karen Mains Procopio’s interview about her debut release, Finding Me, FIND IT HERE.



52 Comments
Deena Adams
Congratulations to Dana McReynolds, the winner of Janell’s giveaway! Please follow the instructions in your email to claim your prize. Thanks to all for reading the post and commenting! Look for a new giveaway on November 11 from Patricia Raybon for her upcoming WWII release, The Sedalia Code!
Janell York
Congratulations, Dana! I’ll get your books in the mail soon. I hope you enjoy them. Janell York
Brianne Haynes
I have not read either book yet but am excited to read them. I have known Janell (Mrs York) since I was in HS, at the time she was a teacher at my school. I have always looked up to her.
Deena Adams
Hi, Brianne. Thanks so much for reading Janell’s post and commenting. I’m sure your support and respect means a lot to her!
Janell York
Hi, Briana. It’s nice to hear from you. Thank you for your sweet comments. I hope you’re doing well, Janell.
Cherie J
No, I have never read any books by her. Janell is a new author me. It sounds like a great series though and this book sounds like a book I would enjoy reading.
Deena Adams
Hi, Cherie. I hope you get a chance to read Janell’s books soon! I think you’d like them. Thanks for stopping by!
Janell York
Hi, Cherie. Thank you for responding. I hope you get a chance to read both book in the series. Janell
Amber G
Loved the first book! Can’t wait to get my hands on the second!!
Deena Adams
I really enjoyed Janell’s first book, too, Amber. I’m sure this one will be great too!
Janell York
Thank you, Amber! I’m so glad you enjoyed the first one. I hope you love Letting Go of Perfect. Janell
Kera
This sounds like a good book, but I have to read the first one first and then I’ll read this one
Deena Adams
I hope you enjoy both books, Kera!
Janell York
Hi. Kera! I hope you enjoy book one and book 2. Thank you for your intrest in the Sisterhood Pie Pact Series. Janell York
Karla Santoro
This is a new author for me! I am intrigued by the story lines. I love reading new Christian fiction, then donating the books to my local library where they are added to the shelves.
Deena Adams
Hi, Karla. Donating books to your library is a great thing to do! I’m sure many readers appreciate that.
Janell York
Hi, Karla! I hope you enjoy both books. I love that you donate to your library, I do too. Janell York
Crystan
The Sisterhood Pie Pact sounds like a great series. I grew up in a small town in Il and now live in a small town in PA. I would love to find a group of supportive girl friends, but it hasn’t happened yet. I’ll just have to keep praying.
Janell York
Hi, Crystan. I’ll be praying for you too. Having a community of women friends is so important. That’s in part why I wrote the series. I’m working on book 3 now. Janell York
Deena Adams
Hi, Crystan. I think I’d enjoy living in a small town. I live in a suburb, so at least it’s not city life! I pray God brings some girlfriends into your life.
Cyndi Newlan
You had me at single parenthood and second chances, book club, small town, and shenanigans! Jane is a new author to me, but this sounds like a great series!
Deena Adams
Thanks for reading Janell’s post and joining the conversation, Cyndi!
Janell York
Hi, Cyndi! I’m glad those tropes stood out to you. Janell York
Wendy Hill
Enter me in the giveaway, but I will be looking out for Janell Goodrich York’s books even if I don’t win. Sounds like interesting characters with relatable conflicts.
Janell York
I hope you enjoy Letting Go of Perfect. It’s the second book in the Sisterhood Pie Pact Series. The Day Sarah Ran Away is the first book. It’s about an empty nester who feels lost after her daughter leaves home. Letting Go of Perfect has the same characters with a few additions.
Deena Adams
You’re entered, Wendy! I hope you get a chance to read Janell’s books. 🙂
Diana Hardt
It sounds like an interesting book. Thank you for sharing.
Deena Adams
You’re welcome, Diana. I hope you get to read it soon!
Vickie
Janell is a new author to me. As one of 17 towns I’ve lived in during my life, a Mayberry sort of town is one of them. I would love to read her book.
Janell York
Hi, Vickie. Thank you for your interest. This is my second novel. My first book was published in 2025. I’m writing a series with the theme of sisterhood and community. Janell Goodrich York
Deena Adams
Hi, Vickie. Living in a Mayberry-type town sounds heavenly to me! Thanks for joining the conversation.
Gigi
“If you enjoy small town nostalgia, second chances, community, friendships, redemption, humor, and a little romance—grab a slice of pie, your favorite beverage, and a copy of Letting Go of Perfect.”
That’s me, and I’d love to! 🙂
Janell York
Hi, Gigi! I love your enthusiasm! You might want to check out the first book in the series – The Day Sarah Ran Away. Here’s the back cover blurb. Janell Goodrich York
A heartfelt tale of discovery and resilience when plans fall apart.
Sarah Goodwin loved her life as a stay-at-home mom, pouring her heart into every moment with her only daughter, Emma. But now, Emma is off at college and rarely visits or answers her calls, leaving Sarah feeling adrift in a sea of routines—no more soccer games, fundraisers, dress shopping, or birthday parties. As each monotonous day blends into the next, Sarah longs for something more.
When Emma announces she’ll be home for the summer to plan her wedding, Sarah is thrilled at the thought of shared dreams, endless to-do lists, and the promise of reconnecting. But her perfect summer quickly unravels when unexpected events send her on a daring journey with new companions—an adventure filled with twists, revelations, and surprises she never saw coming.
As Sarah journeys west, questions loom. What will her husband do when he discovers she’s gone? Where will this journey lead her? And most importantly, what lies ahead for Sarah now?
The Day Sarah Ran Away is a 2026 Selah Finalist.
Deena Adams
Love your comment, Gigi! Thanks for stopping by!
Elsie Kappler
I am commenting for the Yanell York giveaway. Hopefully this will work. The Lord be with you all
Deena Adams
Yes, your comment came through, Elsie. You’re entered!
Joan Osborne
I haven’t read these books but the do send like ones I’d enjoy.
Deena Adams
I believe you would, Joan. I hope you get a chance to read Janell’s books!
Janell York
Hi, Joan. If you enjoy small towns, road trips, empty nester, and close female friendships, I think you’ll enjoy both books in the series. At least, I hope so. Janell York
Dana McReynolds
I have not read it but both sound great and what a beautiful cover!
Janell York
Thank you, Dana. ❤️
Deena Adams
Thanks so much for joining the conversation, Dana!
Regina Ballard
I haven’t read The Day Sarah Ran Away, but I believe I would like it, as well as the new book!
Janell York
Hi, Regina. I’m excited your interested in reading my debut novel and the second book in the Sisterhood Pie Pact Seties.
Janell York
Hi, Regina. Thank you for your interest.
Here’s the back book cover blurb for the Day Sarah Ran Away. It’s book one in the Sisterhood Pie Pact series.
A heartfelt tale of discovery and resilience when plans fall apart.
Sarah Goodwin loved her life as a stay-at-home mom, pouring her heart into every moment with her only daughter, Emma. But now, Emma is off at college and rarely visits or answers her calls, leaving Sarah feeling adrift in a sea of routines—no more soccer games, fundraisers, dress shopping, or birthday parties. As each monotonous day blends into the next, Sarah longs for something more.
When Emma announces she’ll be home for the summer to plan her wedding, Sarah is thrilled at the thought of shared dreams, endless to-do lists, and the promise of reconnecting. But her perfect summer quickly unravels when unexpected events send her on a daring journey with new companions—an adventure filled with twists, revelations, and surprises she never saw coming.
As Sarah journeys west, questions loom. What will her husband do when he discovers she’s gone? Where will this journey lead her? And most importantly, what lies ahead for Sarah now?
Deena Adams
I think so, too, Regina!
Melanie Grace
These sound like the “perfect ” books for me to read! Loving the cover.
Deena Adams
Yes, I see what you did there, Melanie. LOL Thanks so much for reading the post and commenting!
Janell York
Hi, Melanie! I think these two books would be “perfect” for you. Janell York
Lori R
This sounds like a fun series!
Deena Adams
Hi, Lori. I agree! I read the first book and really enjoyed the ladies’ shenanigans. LOL. I’m sure this second book will be great too! Thanks for stopping by.
Janell York
Hi. Lori! I had a lot of fun writing them with a little bit of humor and a whole lot of heart. Thank you for your interest. Janell York